Tractate 12
The flow into the Father and the soul's fall into nothing
Tractate 12 (Evans numbering)
In brief
This piece is not a sermon on a Bible verse but a short, dense treatise on the inner life of God and how the soul is drawn into it. Eckhart starts from a distinction he uses often: the Godhead as bare divine nature, and the Father as the Person who receives that nature and from it begets the Son. He then turns to the soul, which he says has two powers fit for this, understanding and will, and traces how each of them can carry a person toward God.
The strangest part of the text is its language of 'the naught', the nothing. Eckhart takes the fearful language people use about hell, being lost in darkness with no way back, and turns it around. The same darkness that terrifies the damned is, for the soul that lets go of everything it thinks it knows and wants, the unknowing where God is found. Losing every name and every hold on herself, the soul sinks into God's own nature and finds nothing missing.
In plain English
Tractate 12
Concerning the flow into the Father, note the following.
The Godhead is contained in the Father as nature, which is why [see Spamer's Texte, B. 2, from which the words in brackets are taken].
he is all-powerful and receives nothing from anything that he is not already himself in his divine potential, since he has it in himself in essence, as his own. Still, when we speak of the Father we mean the Person of the Father, and when we speak of the Godhead we mean his nature, his undivided substance, that is to say. Now since this nature stays brooding in settled, unmoving stillness, moving all things which have proceeded in eternity in the word of his power (or potential Word), it follows that, as power, it has always been flowing into the Father, making him able to beget a Son like himself. We can prove it this way. The Persons are powerless as Persons; whatever they do is done by virtue of their nature, which is their real being. So much for the flow into the Father which he has from his own nature, in which he is all-powerful.
Now mark this. The soul has received two powers by nature. The first of these powers is understanding. This grasps the Trinity, although it is beyond grasping, and all its works. Notice how understanding grasps the Trinity and all its works, even though the Trinity cannot be grasped. The soul in her understanding is the image of the Son, and the Son is the Father's understanding. So when the soul is empty of her own understanding, and only the Son is her understanding, she understands with the Son the Son and the Father and their shared Spirit. That is how the soul grasps the Trinity and all its works.
Her other power is will. Its nature is to throw itself into the unknown, which is God. God is said to be unknown because no creature knows him as he knows himself; known to himself, he is unknown to all creatures. This is why we call God agnosia. Now the chief power of the soul is too particular to spend itself on temporal, known things, so free will boldly leaves behind the known and holds to what it does not know. As St Paul says, 'I do not know, God knows.'
Christ says, 'When I am lifted up I will draw all things to myself.' He means that when he dawns on our heart and understanding, he gathers us up into himself. In this sense all creatures are one man, and that man is God. [In this sense man is all things, for he has the nature of all creatures, and souls joined to Christ are in this sense one man with him. He is the head and they are his members, who live in his love.] In Christ everything was gathered into one. His higher and his lower faculties, and the senses of his outward and his inward man, were in harmonious union with his highest power, conceived there by divine conception, which was united with him in one Person. And so it is with the man in whom all creatures end, in whom all the many things have been reduced to one in Christ: such a man is then one in God with Christ's humanity. In this way all creatures are one man, and that man is God
in the Person of Christ. As one master says, 'One spirit with God and one body with Christ, that is unity indeed.'
With the powers received from the Trinity, the soul knows the ordering of all things as God has arranged them, in such an exalted way. But those who turn their eyes away from God fall back into the very same nothing they were in before they received the likeness of the Trinity, this likeness of the Trinity always reminding them of the dark nothing they are returning to. In this darkness all the pains of hell gather. The darkness wraps around them and hides the sight of God; it burns them beyond any comfort from their created being. This is bitter to their conscience, which condemns them for all time. In this pit of nothingness they sink forever, unable to grasp the nothing they were before they had the likeness of the Trinity.
And now, my children, let us look carefully at these dark sayings. You will see the plain meaning concerning the damned. But another, spiritual, sense lies hidden in them, which you should note especially. This applies to the chosen, who turn their mind away from God and flow back into that same nothing, for when the soul is carried by her understanding above all things and beyond the reach of her own understanding to the understanding of the highest good, she sees that to all creatures this is beyond understanding. So down she goes with her own understanding.
The particular soul can rest her understanding on nothing that has a name. She escapes from every name into the nameless nothingness. Escaping her own nature she falls clear of anything of her own. The nothing she falls into is the unknowing, which is called the dark. In this dark all the pains of hell gather, where the soul is plunged straight into the void. This only happens when she is completely without knowledge. The slightest trace of knowledge or understanding of the nothing she is plunged into would be torment to her like hell. All sense and knowledge of the nothing ends in this darkness. The darkness burns them beyond healing by anything of their own kind. Bitter is this conscience which condemns them for all time. In this abyss of nothingness they sink forever, unable to grasp the nothing they were before they took on the likeness of the Trinity. By virtue of this they have their being. To fathom the nothing in which they drown, they are as helpless as they were when they did not exist. All sense and knowledge end in the darkness of their nothing. For this darkness is the incomprehensible nature of God. She sinks forever into the depths of this nothing. She sinks and drowns; she drowns to anything of her own. What remains of her own being sinks as nothing into nothing. But the nothing that sinks can never grasp the nothing it sinks into. Once every virtue is mastered and gone beyond, the soul cries out: even
so I cannot glorify and love God fully. I die then to the virtues that cast me into the nothing of the Godhead, to sink forever from nothing into something.' The highest reward of love and praise the soul can give the highest good is given in the knowledge that all her love and praise fall short of God. So down she goes through the little she can call her own, and dying to her virtues, she is cast into the nothing of her own self.
Note two points here. She casts herself in with the nothing of herself when, stripped of her exalted power, she always regards her own insignificance.
The other nothing she plunges into is the nothing of the Godhead. Seeing that she herself is nothing and has no wish to settle on anything, the soul casts herself into the nothing of the Godhead and so comes with nothing to nothing. She wants whatever she recognizes in herself to perish into the nothing that is its true being, and so to exist in unity. She sees that we cannot love and glorify God any better than by recognizing how inadequate all our love and glory are. This is why she keeps silent. St Dionysius, setting out to praise Mary's virtues, found them so far beyond conceiving that he fell silent. By his silence the worthy Dionysius paid Mary the highest honor. This is what happens to the soul when she is caught up into God's incomprehensibility. With her lips struck dumb, 'O groundless Truth,' she cries, 'how poor our praise is!' In this way she comes into a union close enough for God to pour himself into her completely and draw her completely into himself, leaving no trace of either vice or virtue; nor does the soul know any difference.
You should know that for the soul in her perfection, goodness would come quite naturally; she would not merely practice virtues, but virtue as a whole would be her life, and she would give it off naturally. We seem to be sinful or virtuous because we are sometimes one and sometimes the other. This should not be so: we ought to be always in a state of perfection. That is one thing to note.
Further, God absorbs the soul, leaving no trace. This means that the soul, caught up by God into the peace and quiet of his hidden self, shows little of this except to those of her own kind. There the soul knows no separation, for the one who has absorbed her has merged her into himself. She knows well that she is, but does not know what she is. The sun in certain countries is too hot for fruit to grow well on the surface of the earth, yet that same sun produces gold in abundance deep in the earth. So it is with the soul in whom the bright sun of the divine nature shines: it produces its own likeness there, scattering the darkness and bringing about perfect unity. Notice this: we should be very gentle with such souls, for, withdrawn into his hiding place, they are out of touch with the world around them.
St Chrysostom says, 'It is not yet clear what we are, but when we are changed into him we will show what we are.' Whatever she may take herself to be, to God she is still a creature.
The Godhead is a spiritual substance, so impenetrable that no one can say what kind of thing it is. It is said that God in the Trinity is the living light in its visible brightness. In other words, the three Persons are one in nature though distinct as Persons, in the same way that the source of light is not the light itself, nor is the source its shining. Applying this to the three Persons: the source is the Father, the Son is the light, and the Holy Spirit is the shining. The Father is the living source in whom all things have lived eternally outside themselves, as in their cause. The light is the Son, in whom all things appear eternally as in their idea. The shining is the Holy Spirit, in whom all things are one eternally as in their nothing. This does not mean that one Person is the life and another the light: the three Persons are one life, one light.
The Trinity is the heart of the divine nature, as you can show. In human life it is the heart that beats in all the limbs, giving them energy and bringing them into order. Because the limbs receive from it, it is called the heart. Now as for the Godhead, this is not active in its own nature, but whatever it does, it does through the Persons, and the Trinity is called the heart of the divine nature because the Godhead works by means of it, and because the Trinity is the origin of all things, and all things flow back into it and come to rest there. This heart of the heart, again, is the highest power of the unity in which and through which it is all-powerful. Human nature flows in love into the Trinity as into its common origin. The unity of the Trinity is without bottom, and nothing is contained in it. In the embrace of this unity the naked soul sinks down forever and never touches bottom. Her temporal powers, that is, the created natures of her faculties, stop at the Persons, while her pure essence is received into the pure unity of God without return.
Look at the soul separated from everything. For whoever stoops to anything that is not God can never be received into God's unity. This unity has no cause; it is its own cause. Its floor has no bottom, its roof has no top, its space has no edge. I am speaking here of the Trinity of Persons: the unity lies beneath it, holding it together; it rises above it, giving it energy; it surrounds it, bringing its distinctions to an end. So the Trinity is in the unity and the unity is in the Trinity. As the psalm Quicumque vult says.
That we should know ourselves and God as far as we are able, this is God's will. If we want to know ourselves, we have to recognize that we are nothing but the raw material of God, for the blessed Trinity to work in. We should therefore take great care not to hinder in any way the work which the exalted
workman intends to carry out in us for his glory, but to keep ourselves ready so that the material is always available for the workman to do his work in us. St Paul says, 'The spirit of the Lord descends from above in secret, working in whoever it wishes, and when and where and how it wishes, in anyone who puts up no hindrance.' This is true in the children of God. They are led by this spirit. This is how you shall know yourselves. Next, we have to know God. To this end St Dionysius urged one of his disciples, saying, 'Rise up, friend, strip yourself of things and put off yourself, so that you may understand the Sovereign Good.' Three things are said of it. First, it is a unique force, whole in everything; second, a unique good embracing everything. Third, to really know God you must know him as the unknown. So Dionysius says.
God's will is our welfare, and our welfare consists in knowing God and acting accordingly. Here timidity murmurs in the soul, both she will and she will not. And hard on this comes a rage of soul. When she senses that it falls to her to be somewhat that he is not, she is carried away with anger. She would sooner come to nothing than have or take anything that belongs to him. 'Lord,' she cries, 'my welfare lies in your never calling me to mind, and I beg you, forbid any creature ever to console me. I rejoice that my powers never come before your face.'
See what the soul means by these strange words: 'my welfare lies in your never calling me to mind.' She knows very well that she has never been out of his mind for one instant, and that is her happiness. She asks not to be comforted by any creature, because she is in a poverty so complete that her very lack of comfort is her one comfort. And what does she mean when she says her powers do not come before his face? Notice what God's face is. We see ourselves best in what we call our face. In the same way God is shown to himself in the hidden stillness of his own being. This showing is called the face of the Godhead. The soul knows well that, together with her powers, she can never enter the complete stillness where he is shown to himself. So she wants her powers not to come before his face, that is, before his self-revealing. Notice, her powers stop at its reflection in the Trinity, and only the pure essence of her spirit is carried straight from the stillness of her own power into this perfect revealing. As a master says: 'Where the pure and the purified are one, the powers of the soul come to an end.' He means that in the one perfect nature the pure nature of the spirit rises above all its powers. Saint Paul says, 'He who is joined to God is one spirit with him.' Amen.
Plain-English version by Gregory Lahn, from C. de B. Evans's translation of Franz Pfeiffer's edition (London, 1924), which is in the public domain.
Read the 1924 translation
THE FLOW INTO THE FATHER
Concerning the flow into the Father, note as follows.
The Godhead is contained in the Father as nature, wherefore he is omnipotent and receives naught from aught that he is not himself in his divine potentiality, seeing that he has it in him in essence, as his own.
* See Spamer's Texte, B. 2, from which the words in brackets are taken.
Nevertheless, speaking of the Father we mean the Person of the Father, and speaking of the Godhead we mean his nature, his impartible substance, that is to say. Now since this nature stays brooding in settled immoveable stillness, moving all things which have proceeded in eternity in the word of his power (or potential Word), it follows that, as power, it has ever been flowing into the Father making him able to beget a Son like unto himself. We can prove it thus. The Persons are impotent as Persons; anything they do is done in virtue of their nature which is their real being. So much for the flow into the Father which he has of his own nature wherein he is omnipotent.
Now mark. The soul has received two powers by nature. The first of these powers is understanding. This comprehends the Trinity, although it is incomprehensible, and all its works. Observe how understanding comprehends the Trinity, and all its works, despite its being incomprehensible. The soul in her understanding is the image of the Son and the Son is the Father's understanding. So when the soul is empty of her own understanding, and only the Son is her understanding, she understands with the Son the Son and the Father and their common Spirit. That is how the soul comprehends the Trinity and all its works.
Her other power is will. It is its nature to cast itself into the unknown which is God. God is said to be unknown because no creature knows him as he knows himself; as known to himself he is unknowing to all creatures. Hence we call God agnosia. Now the chief power of the soul is too fastidious to dally with temporal, known things, so free will boldly disregards the known and cleaves to what it knows not. As St Paul says, 'I know not; God knoweth.'
Christ says, 'When I am ascended I will draw all things to me.' He means that when he dawns upon our heart and understanding he gathers us up into himself. In this sense all creatures are one man and that man is God. [In this sense man is all things. For he has the nature of all creatures, and souls joined to Christ are in this sense one man with him. He is the head and they are his members, who are in his charity.] In Christ his all was assembled into one. His higher and his lower faculties, and the senses of his outward and his inward man were in harmonious union with his highest power, conceived there by divine conception, which was united with him in one Person. And so with the man in whom all creatures end, in whom all multitudinous things have been reduced to one in Christ: man is then one in God with Christ's humanity. Thus all creatures are one man and that man is God in Christ's Person. As one master says: With God one spirit and with Christ one body, that is unity indeed.
With the powers received from the Trinity the soul knows the ordering of all things ordained by God in such exalted fashion. But those that turn away their eyes from God relapse into the self-same naught wherein they were before they had received the likeness of the Trinity, this likeness of the Trinity aye informing them of the dark nothing back to which they wend. In this darkness gather all the pangs of hell. The dark enwraps them and hides the sight of God; it burns them past soothing by their created aught. This is bitter to their conscience which damns them to all time. In this pit of nothingness they sink for evermore, powerless to grasp the naught they were before they had the likeness of the Trinity.
And now, my children, let us examine these dark sayings carefully. You will see the obvious meaning of these damned. But another, ghostly, sense lies hid therein, which it behoves you to note specially. This applies to the elect who turn away their mind from God and flow back into that same naught, for when the soul is carried by her understanding above all things and beyond the scope of her own understanding to the understanding of the sovran good she sees that to all creatures this is unintelligible. So down she goes with her own understanding.
The fastidious soul can rest her understanding on nothing that has name. She escapes from every name into the nameless nothingness. Escaping her own nature she falls clear of her own aught. The naught she falls into is the unknowing, which is called the dark. In this dark 'gather the pangs of hell,' where the soul is plunged sheer into the void. This only happens when she is perfectly devoid of knowledge. The slightest trace of knowledge or understanding of the naught that she is plunged in would be hell-torment to her. All sense and knowledge of the naught ends in this darkness. The darkness burns them past salving by any of their kind. Bitter is this conscience which damns them to all time. 'In this abyss of nothingness they sink for evermore, failing to grasp the naught they were before they took the likeness of the Trinity.' By virtue whereof they have their being. To approfound the naught wherein they drown they are as helpless as they were when they were not. All sense and knowledge end in the darkness of their naught. For this darkness is the incomprehensible nature of God. She sinks for evermore in the depths of this naught. She sinks and drowns; she drowns to her own aught. Her aught, surviving, sinks as naught to naught. But the naught that sinks can never comprehend the naught it sinks in. Every virtue mastered and transcended, the soul cries: 'Even so I cannot glorify and love God to the full. I die then to the virtues casting me into the naught of the Godhead to sink eternally from naught to aught.' The highest meed of love and praise the soul can lavish on the sovran good is given in the knowledge that all her love and praise fall short of God. So down she goes through the little she can call her own and dying to her virtues is cast into the naught of her own self.
Two points mark here. She casts herself with the naught of herself when, self-bereft of her exalted power she ever regards her own insignificance.
The other naught she plunges in is the naught of the Godhead. Seeing that she herself is naught and not disposed to stay at aught, the soul casts herself into the naught of the Godhead and so comes with naught to naught. She wants the aught she recognises in herself to perish in the naught which is its very aught and so subsist in unity. She sees we cannot love and glorify God better than by recognising how inadequate all love and glory are. Wherefore she holds her peace. St Dionysius being bent on lauding Mary's virtues found them so inconceivable he held his tongue. By his dumbness the worthy Dionysius did Mary highest honour. Thus it befalls the soul on being ravished into God's incomprehensibility. Her lips struck dumb, 'O groundless Truth,' she cries, 'how paltry is our praise!' So she attains to union close enough for God to pour himself into her every whit and snatch her every whit into himself, leaving no trace of either vice or virtue; nor does the soul know any difference.
For you must know that to the soul in her perfection goodness would come quite natural; she would not merely practise virtues, but vir
St Chrysostom says, "It is not yet manifest what we are, but when we are changed into him we shall show what we are." Whatever she may take herself for, to God she is creature.
The Godhead is a spiritual substance, so impenetrable that none can say what manner of thing it is. They say: God in the Trinity is the living light in its visible radiance. In other words, the three Persons are but one in nature though distinct in Person in the same sense that the source of light is not the light nor is the source its shine. Applying this to the three Persons, the source is the Father, the Son is the light and the Holy Ghost is the shine. The Father is the living source in whom all things have lived eternally without themselves as in their cause. The light is the Son in whom all things appear eternally as in their idea. The shine is the Holy Ghost in whom all things are one eternally as in their naught. Not that one Person is the life and another the light: the three Persons are one life, one light.
The Trinity is the heart of the divine nature. As you may prove. For in human life it is the heart which beats in all the limbs, energising, co-ordinating them. Because the limbs receive from it, therefore it is called the heart. Now touching the Godhead, this is not active in its nature, but anything it does it does with the Persons, and the Trinity is called the heart of divine nature because this works by means of it, and because it (the Trinity) is the origin of all things and all things flow back into it and end. This heart's heart, again, is the paramount power of the unity wherein and whereby it is omnipotent. Human nature flows in love into the Trinity as into its universal origin. The unity of the Trinity is bottomless and nothing is contained therein. In the embrace of unity the naked soul sinks down for aye nor ever touches bottom. Her temporalities (i.e. the created natures of her powers) stop at the Persons, whereas her pure essence is received by the pure unity of God without return.
Behold the soul divorced from every aught. For he who stoops to aught that is not God can never be received into God's unity. This unity is causeless; it is self-caused. Of bottomless depth the floor, of endless height the roof, of boundless space the rim. I refer to the Trinity of Persons: the unity underlies it, holding it together; it overtops it, energising it; it surrounds it, ending its distinctions. Thus the Trinity is in the unity and the unity in the Trinity. As saith the psalm Quicumque vult.
That we should know ourselves and God so far as we are able, that is God's will. If we would know ourselves we have to recognise that we are nothing but the raw material of God for the blessed Trinity to work in. It behoves us therefore to be vastly careful not to hamper in any way the work which the exalted workman designs to carry out in us to his glory, but so to maintain ourselves that the material is always ready for the workman to do his work in us. St Paul says, "The spirit of the Lord descends from on high in secret, working in whom it will and when and where and how it will in him in whom it meets no hindrance." In the children of God. They are led by this spirit. — It is thus ye shall know yourselves. Next, we have to know God. To this St Dionysius exhorted one of his disciples, saying, "Up, friend, divest thyself of things and put off thyself that thou mayst understand the Sovran Good." Of it three things are predicated. First, it is a unique force entire in everything; next, a unique good embracing everything. Thirdly, to know God really ye must know him as the unknown. So Dionysius says.
God's will is our welfare, and our welfare consists in knowing God and doing accordingly. Here timorousness mutters in the soul, both she will and she will not. And hard on this comes rage of soul. When she divines that it remains for her to be somewhat that he is not, she is transported with ire. She would sooner come to naught than have or take aught that belongs to him. "Lord," she cries, "my welfare lies in thy never calling me to mind; and forbid, I pray thee, any creature ever to console me. I rejoice that my powers never come before thy face."
See what the soul means by her strange words: "my welfare lies in thy never calling me to mind." She wots right well that she has never been one instant out of his mind and that is her felicity. She begs not to be comforted by any creature, because she is in indigence right comfortless where her disconsolateness is her one consolation. And when she says her powers come not before his face? Observe what God's face is. We see ourselves best in what is called our face. So too where God is manifest to himself in the mysterious stillness of his own essence. This revelation is called the face of the Godhead. The soul is well aware that, accompanied by her powers, she can never enter the absolute stillness where he is manifest to himself. Hence she desires her powers not to come before his face, i.e. his self-revelation. See, her powers halt at its reflection in the Trinity and only the pure essence of her spirit is flashed from the stillness of her own power straight into this perfect revelation. As a master says: "Where pure and purified are one the powers of the soul are at an end." Meaning that in the one perfect nature the pure nature of the spirit transcends all its powers. St Paul says, "He who is joined to God is one spirit with him." Amen.
Go deeper with this tractate
The spiritual guide to Tractate 12
The guide walks you through the inner journey this tractate describes, where it meets your own days, and the ways people go wrong trying to live it. It ends with a practice for the week, a meditation and questions for reflection.
It is in Sermons of Meister Eckhart, Explained, Volume 9.
Live this teaching
The Godhead beyond God is Week 6 of The Ground of the Soul
An 8-week guided path with daily practices, weekly guided audio and a workbook.
Free by email
30 Days with Meister Eckhart
One short passage from his sermons each day for thirty days, with a plain paragraph on what he means. It is free, and leaving takes one click.