Meister Eckhart

Library › Sermon 4

Sermon 4

The eternal birth: finding God in the ground of the soul

Sermon 4 (Evans numbering). On Et cum factus esset Jesus annorum duodecim etc. (Luke 2)

In brief

Eckhart starts from the gospel story of the boy Jesus lost in the temple crowd and found again only when his parents go back to where they started. He reads this as a picture of the soul. We lose God by looking for him among the things we already know: our memories, our ideas, our sense of ourselves. We find him only by going back to the ground we came from, underneath all of that.

From there he builds an argument that gets more demanding as it goes. No idea of God, however good, is God himself. The mind has to give up trying to grasp him and sit in something like darkness, with no comfortable way back to its old busyness. And yet, he says, God cannot hold back once a person is actually empty and ready. The sermon ends by saying that love, not harsh discipline, is what really holds a person to God.

In plain English

Sermon 4

Et cum factus esset Jesus annorum duodecim, etc. (Luke 2): And when Jesus was twelve years old, etc. We read in the gospel that when our Lord was twelve years old, he went with Joseph and Mary to Jerusalem, into the temple. When they left, Jesus stayed behind in the temple without their knowing it. When they got home and missed him, they looked for him among people they knew and among strangers, among their relatives and in the crowd, and did not find him. They had lost him in the crowd. So there was nothing to do but go back the way they had come, and when they got back to where they started, into the temple, there they found him.

If you want to find this noble birth, you must truly leave the crowd and go back to the starting point, into the ground you came from. The powers of the soul and their workings, these are the crowd: memory, understanding and will all scatter you into many things, so you must leave them all behind: sense perception, imagination, and everything in which you find yourself and keep yourself in view. After that you may find this birth, but believe me, not otherwise. He has never been found among friends, nor among relatives, nor among acquaintances. There, rather, one loses him altogether.

Now the question arises whether this birth can be found in anything that, though it relates to God, is still taken in from outside through the senses, in any picture of God as good, or wise, or compassionate, or in whatever the intellect can conceive about divinity. Can this birth be found in anything of that kind? In truth, no. For although these things are good and godlike, they still come in from outside through the senses. Everything must well up from within, out of God, if this birth is to shine with a truly clear light, and your own work must be set aside, with every faculty serving his purposes and not your own. If this work is to be done, God alone must do it, and you must simply undergo it. Where you truly go out from your own willing and knowing, God surely and willingly goes in with his knowing and shines there clearly. Where God thus knows himself, your knowledge is of no use and cannot stand. Do not imagine, however fondly, that your reason can grow into the knowledge of God. No natural light can help bring it about that God shines in you in a godly way. It must be utterly put out and go altogether out of itself, and then God can shine in with his light, bringing back with him everything you went out of, and a thousand times more, along with the new form that holds it all.

We have an image of this in the gospel. When our Lord had spoken so kindly with the Gentile woman at the well, she left her water jar there and ran to the town to tell her people that the true Messiah had come. The people did not believe her report, so they went out with her to see him for themselves. Then they said to her, 'Now we believe, for we have seen him ourselves.' In truth, neither by any created knowledge nor by your own wisdom can you be brought to know God in a godly way. To know God the way God knows, your knowledge must turn into a plain unknowing, into a forgetting of yourself and every creature.

Now perhaps you will say: Tell me, sir, what good is my intellect if it must be inert and completely idle? Is it my best course to raise my mind to this unknowing knowing, which plainly cannot be anything? For if I knew something, it would not be ignorance, and I would not be idle and empty. Must I stay in total darkness?

Yes, truly. You can do no better than to make your home in total darkness and ignorance.

Alas, sir, must everything go then, and is there no way back?

No, truly. By rights there is no way back.

But what is this darkness? What does it mean, what is its name?

It can only be called a potential receptiveness, which is nevertheless not altogether lacking in real being, or in need of it: the merely potential state in which you will be made complete. So there is no way back from it. If you turn back, it is not because of any truth, it is because of the senses, the world or the devil. And by persisting in this turning back you inevitably fall into sin, and you risk slipping so far as to have the eternal fall. So there is no turning back, only a pressing forward, following this possibility through to its fulfillment. It never rests until it is filled with all being. Just as matter never rests until it is filled with every possible form, so the intellect never rests until it is filled to the full extent of its capacity.

On this a pagan master says: 'Nature has nothing swifter than the heavens, which surpass everything else in swiftness.' But the mind of man surely outstrips them. Provided it keeps its vigor and is not degraded or torn apart by what is base and coarse, it can outstrip the high heavens and need not slacken until it reaches the summit, where it is fed and cherished by the highest good, by God himself.

How worthwhile it is, then, to take hold of this possibility. By keeping yourself empty and bare, simply tracking and following and giving yourself up to this darkness and ignorance without turning back, you may indeed win that which is all things. And the more you are stripped of yourself and ignorant of things, the nearer you are to it. Of this bareness it is written in Hosea: 'I will lead my friend into the desert and speak to her heart.' The true Word of eternity is spoken only in eternity, where man is a desert and a stranger to himself and to multiplicity. The prophet longed for this desolate estrangement from self, saying: 'Who will give me the wings of a dove, that I may fly away and be at rest!' Where shall I find peace and rest? Truly, in rejection, in desolation and estrangement from all creatures. That is why David says: 'I would rather be an outcast in the house of my God than have honor and riches in the tents of sinners.'

Now perhaps you will say: Alas, sir, must a person really be stripped bare and made a stranger to everything, outward and inward? Must the powers and their workings all go? It seems a hard thing for a person to be left this way by God without any support, for God to add to his misery like this, neither giving light nor encouragement nor working in him, since that is what your teaching amounts to. For someone in such complete nothingness, would it not be better to be doing something to ease the gloom and desolation, to pray or read or go to church, or else find something useful to occupy himself with?

No, be sure of this: complete stillness, complete idleness, is best of all. Know that you cannot exchange this state for any other without harm. You would gladly do part of the preparing yourself and let God do the rest, but it cannot work that way. However quick you are to think of this readiness and want it, God is always there before you. But even granting what is actually impossible, that the preparation for this work or this pouring-in is shared between him and you, know this: God is bound to act, to pour himself out into you, the moment he finds you ready. God differs from a human carpenter, who works or does not work as he pleases, who can do a thing or leave it undone at will. Finding you ready, he is obliged to act, to overflow into you, just as the sun must burst forth when the air is bright and clear and cannot hold itself back. Truly it would be a serious failing in God if, finding you so empty and so bare, he did not work some excellent work in you, or fill you with glorious gifts.

In the same way philosophers say that the moment the material for a child is ready in the mother's womb, God pours into the body its living spirit, that is, the soul, the form of the body. The being-ready and the pouring-in happen in a single flash. When nature reaches her summit, God gives his grace: the instant the spirit is ready, God enters without hesitation or delay. It is written in the book of Revelation that our Lord offers himself to men: 'Behold, I stand at the door and knock, waiting for someone to let me in, and I will eat with him.' You need not seek him here or there, he is no further off than the door of your heart. There he stands waiting for whoever is ready to open and let him in. You need not call to him from far away, he waits far more impatiently than you do for you to open to him. He longs for you a thousand times more urgently than you long for him. The opening and the entering are one point.

You will perhaps say: How can that be? I have no sense of him at all. Know that finding him is not within your power, but within his. He reveals himself when he chooses, and he hides himself too when he chooses. This is what Christ meant when he said to Nicodemus, 'The spirit blows where it wills, you hear its voice but do not know where it comes from or where it goes.' This sounds like a contradiction: you hear but do not know. By hearing, we know. Christ meant that through hearing it is taken in and absorbed, as if to say: you receive it without being aware of it. For know this, God cannot leave anything empty and unfilled. Nature's God cannot bear for anything to be empty or void. So if it seems to you that you cannot find him, and that you are completely empty of him, that is still not the case. For if there were any emptiness anywhere under heaven, whatever it might be, great or small, the heavens would either draw it up to themselves, or bend down and fill it with themselves. God, the lord of nature, does not allow anything whatsoever to remain empty. So stand still and do not waver, in case by turning away from God now, for just a moment, you never turn back to him again.

Perhaps you will say: Well, sir, since you keep assuming that someday this birth will happen in me, that the Son will be born in me, can I have some sign by which I will recognize that it has taken place?

Yes, truly. There would be three signs. I will tell you one of them. I am often asked whether it is possible to reach a point where nothing in time can hinder you, neither multiplicity nor matter. Indeed it is. If this birth really happens, no creature can hinder you, everything points you toward God and toward this birth. We find an image of this in lightning. Whatever it strikes, whether tree, animal or person, it turns toward itself in the shock. A person with his back to it instantly spins around to face it, and all the thousand leaves of a tree turn over to meet the stroke. So it is with everyone this birth happens to, they are at once turned toward this birth by everything present, however earthly it may be. In fact, what was once a hindrance now becomes nothing but a help. Your face is turned so fully toward this birth that no matter what you see or hear, you receive nothing but this birth in everything. All things simply become God to you, because you see only God in all things. It is like someone who has looked long at the sun and then meets the sun again in whatever he looks at afterward. If this is missing, this looking for and seeing God in everything without exception, then you are missing this birth.

You may ask: should someone in this condition still practice penance? Does he lose anything by giving up penitential exercises?

Penitential practices, among other things, were set up for a particular purpose. Fasting, keeping vigil, praying, kneeling, scourging, wearing hair shirts, sleeping on hard ground, or whatever else it may be, were all devised because body and flesh always stand opposed to spirit. The body is far too strong for the spirit, so there is always a battle joined between them, a conflict without end. Here the body is bold and strong, because here it is at home. The world helps it, the earth is its homeland, it is supported by all its own kind: food, drink, comfort, all of it stands against the spirit. The spirit is a stranger here, its kindred and its whole people are in heaven, there its loved ones live. To help the spirit in its distress, and to hold the flesh back somewhat in this struggle so that it does not conquer the spirit, we put on it the bridle of penitential practices, to curb it so that the spirit can control it. This is done to bring it under control, but to conquer it and curb it

A thousand times better, put on it the bridle of love. With love you overcome it most surely, with love you load it most heavily. God lies in wait for us therefore with nothing so much as with love. For love is like the fisherman's hook. No fish falls to the fisherman that is not caught on his hook. Once it takes the hook the fish belongs to the fisherman; in vain it twists this way and that, the fisherman is certain of his catch. And so I say of love: he who is caught by it has the strongest of all bonds and yet a pleasant burden. He who carries this sweet burden goes further, gets nearer by it than by using any harshness a person is capable of. What is more, he can cheerfully put up with whatever happens to him, cheerfully suffer whatever God sends. Nothing makes you so much God's, nor God so much your own, as this sweet bond. He who has found this way will look for no other. He who hangs on this hook is caught so fast that foot and hand, mouth, eyes and heart and everything that belongs to a person is bound to become God's.

So then you cannot, better than by love, overcome your enemy and stop him doing you harm. This is why it is written: 'Love is strong as death and hard as hell.' Death separates soul from body, but love separates all things from the soul; she will not put up with, at any cost, whatever is not God or God's. Whoever is caught in this net, whoever walks in this way, whatever he does is done by love, and the work belongs to love alone: busy or idle, it makes no difference. Such a person's smallest action is more worthwhile, his humblest task is more fruitful for himself and for others, and more pleasing to God, than the combined works of other people who, though free of mortal sin, are still beneath him in love. He rests to more purpose than others labor.

Wait, then, for this book, so that you may be happily caught, and the more surely you are caught the more surely you will be set free.

That we may be caught and set free in this way, help us, you who are love itself. Amen.

Plain-English version by Gregory Lahn, from C. de B. Evans's translation of Franz Pfeiffer's edition (London, 1924), which is in the public domain.

Read the 1924 translation

THE ETERNAL BIRTH

Et cum factus esset Jesus annorum duodecim etc. (Luc. 2.) We read in the gospel that when our Lord was twelve years old he went with Joseph and Mary to Jerusalem into the temple; and when they went out, Jesus remained behind in the temple without their knowing it. And when they reached home and missed him, they sought him among acquaintances and among strangers, among their kindred, and among the multitude, and found him not; they had lost him in the crowd. So there was nothing for it but to return whence they were come; and when they got back to their starting-point, into the temple, there they found him.

If thou wilt find this noble birth, verily thou must quit the multitude and return to the starting-point, into the ground out of which thou art come. The powers of the soul and their works, these are the multitude: memory, understanding and will, these all diversify thee, therefore thou must leave them all: sensible perception, imagination and everything wherein thou findest thyself and hast thyself in view. Thereafter thou mayest find this birth, but, believe me, not otherwise. He has never been found among friends, nor among kindred nor acquaintances, there rather does one lose him altogether.

Now the question arises, whether this birth is to be found in anything which, albeit relating to God, is nevertheless taken in from without through the senses, in any presentment of God as good, wise, or compassionate, or whatever intellect can conceive of divinity: whether this birth is to be found in any such-like things? In truth, no! for, although good and godlike, they are nevertheless introduced from without through the senses; all must well up from within, out of God, if this birth is to shine with a really clear light, and thy own work must lie over, every faculty serving his ends not thine own. If this work is to be done, God alone must do it, and thou must undergo it. Where from thy willing and knowing thou truly goest out, God with his knowing surely and willingly goes in and shines there clearly. Where God thus knows himself thy knowledge is of no avail and cannot stand. Do not fondly imagine that thy reason can grow to the knowledge of God; that God shall shine in thee divinely no natural light can help to bring about; it must be utterly extinguished and go out of itself altogether, then God can shine in with his light bringing back with him everything thou wentest out of and a thousandfold more, besides the new form containing it all.

Of this we have an allegory in the gospel. When our Lord had talked so friendly with the Gentile woman at the well, she left her pitcher there, and running to the town announced to her people that the true Messiah was come. The people, not believing her report, went out with her to see him for themselves. Then said they unto her, 'Now we believe, not because of thy words, but because we have seen him in person.' Verily, neither by any creaturely science nor by thine own wisdom canst thou be brought to know God divinely. To know God God-fashion, thy knowledge must change into downright unknowing, to a forgetting of thyself and every creature.

Now haply thou wilt say: 'Prithee, Sir, what is the use of my intellect if it has to be inert and altogether idle? Is it my best plan to raise my mind to the unknowing knowing which obviously cannot be anything? For if I knew anything it would not be ignorance, nor should I be idle and destitute. Must I remain in total darkness?'

-- Aye, surely! Thou canst do no better than take up thy abode in total darkness and ignorance.

-- Alas, Sir! must everything go then, and is there no return?'

-- No, truly! By rights there is no return.

-- But what is this darkness? What does it mean, what is its name?'

-- It can only be called a potential receptivity, which, however, is not altogether wanting in nor indigent of (real) being: the merely potential conception wherein thou shalt be perfected. Hence there is no return from it. An thou returnest it is not because of any truth; it is either the senses, the world or the devil. And persisting in this turning back, thou dost inevitably lapse into sin and art liable to backslide so far as to have the eternal fall. Wherefore there is no turning back, only a pressing forward and following up this possibility to its fulfilment. It never rests until fulfilled with all being. As matter never rests until fulfilled with every possible form, so intellect never rests till it is filled to the full of its capacity.

Concerning this a heathen master says: 'Nature has nothing swifter than the heavens which surpass all else in swiftness.' But surely the mind of man outstrips them. Given that it retains its vigour and stays undemeaned and undismembered by what is base and gross, it can outstrip high heaven nor slacken till the summit, where it is fed and cherished by the Arch-Good, by God himself.

How profitable then to seize this possibility, for by keeping thyself empty and bare, merely tracking and following and giving up thyself to this darkness and ignorance without turning back, thou mayest well win that which is all things. And the more thou art barren of thyself and ignorant of things the nearer thou art thereto. Of this barrenness it is written in Hosea: 'I will lead my friend into the desert and will speak to her in her heart.' The genuine Word of eternity is spoken only in eternity, where man is a desert and alien to himself and multiplicity. For this desolate self-estrangement the prophet longed, saying: 'Who will give me the wings of a dove that I may fly away and be at rest!' Where shall I find peace and rest? Verily in rejection, in desolation and estrangement from all creatures. Wherefore David says: 'I had rather be an abject in the house of my God than have honour and riches in the tabernacles of sinners.'

Now haply thou wilt say: 'Alas, Sir, after all, is it necessary to be barren and estranged from everything, outward and inward: the powers and their works, must all go? It is a grievous matter for a man thus to be left by God without support; for God to thus augment his misery, neither enlightening nor encouraging nor working in him, for that is what your teaching means. For a person in such downright nothingness would it not be better to be doing something to beguile the gloom and desolation; to pray or read or go to church or else make shift by working at some useful occupation?'

No, be sure of this: absolute stillness, absolute idleness is best of all. Know that thou canst not without harm exchange this state for any other whatsoever. Fain wouldst thou partly fit thyself and let God partly fit thee, but that cannot be. Art never so quick to think of this fitness and desire it, God forestalls thee always. But granting, what is impossible, that it is shared: that the preparation for this working or infusion is jointly his and thine, know then, that God is bound to act, to pour himself out (into thee) as soon as ever he shall find thee ready. Think not it is with God as with a human carpenter, who works or works not as he chooses, who can do or leave undone at his good pleasure. It is not thus with God; but finding thee ready he is obliged to act, to overflow into thee; just as the sun must needs burst forth when the air is bright and clear, and is unable to contain itself. Forsooth, it were a very grave defect in God if, finding thee so empty and so bare, he wrought no excellent work in thee nor primed thee with glorious gifts.

In the same sense philosophers declare that the instant the child-stuff is ready in the mother's womb, God pours into the body its living spirit, that is, the soul, the form of the body. It is one flash, the being-ready and the pouring-in. Nature reaching her summit, God dispenses his grace: the instant the spirit is ready God enters without hesitation or delay. In the book of Mystery it is written that our Lord offers himself to men: 'Behold I stand at the door and knock, waiting for someone to let me in, with him will I sup.' Thou needst not seek him here or there, he is no further off than at the door of thy heart; there he stands lingering, awaiting whoever is ready to open and let him in. Thou needst not call to him afar, he waits much more impatiently than thou for thee to open to him. He longs for thee a thousandfold more urgently than thou for him: one point the opening and the entering.

Thou wilt say, perhaps: 'How can that be? I have no inkling of him.' Know, that to find him is not in thy power but in his. He discovers himself when he chooses and he hides himself too when he will. This is what Christ meant when he said to Nicodemus, 'The spirit breatheth where he will; thou hearest his voice, but knowest not whence he cometh nor whither he goeth.' This is a contradiction: 'Thou hearest but knowest not.' By hearing we know. Christ meant that through hearing it is imbibed or absorbed; as though to say: thou receivest it but unawares. For know, God cannot leave anything void and unfilled; that aught should be empty or void is not to be endured by nature's God. An thou seemest, therefore, not to find him and to be wholly empty of him, yet that is not the case. For were there any emptiness under heaven, whatever it might be, or great or small, the heavens must either draw it up to them or, bending downwards, fill it with themselves. God, nature's lord, on no account permits of anything remaining empty. Wherefore stand still and waver not, lest turning away from God now for the moment thou never turn back to him again.

Peradventure thou wilt say: Well, Sir, since you are always assuming that some day this birth will happen in me, that the Son will be born in me, can I have any sign whereby to recognise that it has taken place?'

Yes, surely! There would be three signs. I will tell you one of them. I am often asked whether it is possible to reach the point of not being hindered by anything in time, either by multiplicity or matter? Indeed it is! If this birth really happens no creature can hinder thee, all point thee to God and this birth. We find in lightning an analogy for this. Whatever it strikes, whether tree, beast or man, it turns towards itself with the shock. A man with his back to it instantly flings round to face it; all the thousand leaves of the tree turn over to front the stroke. So with all whom this birth befalls, they are promptly turned towards this birth with everything present, be it never so earthly. Nay, even what was formerly a hindrance is now nothing but a help. Thy face is turned so full towards this birth, no matter what thou dost see and hear, thou receivest nothing save this birth in anything. All things are simply God to thee who seest only God in all things. Like one who looks long at the sun, he encounters the sun in whatever he afterwards looks at. If this is lacking, this looking for and seeing God in all and sundry, then thou lackest this birth.

Thou mayest question: Ought anyone so placed to practise penance? Does he lose anything by dropping penitential exercises?'

Penitential practices, among other things, were instituted for a special object. Fasting, watching, praying, kneeling, scourging, wearing of hair shirts, hard lying or whatever it may be, were all invented because body and flesh stand ever opposed to spirit. The body being far too strong for it, there is always battle joined between them, a never-ending conflict. Here the body is bold and strong for here it is at home; the world helps it, the earth is its fatherland, it is helped by all its kindred: food, drink, ease -- all are opposed to spirit. The spirit is an alien here, in heaven are its kindred, its whole race; there dwell its loved ones. To succour the spirit in its distress and to impede the flesh somewhat in this strife lest it conquer the spirit, we put upon it the bridle of penitential practices to curb it, so that the spirit can control it. This is done to bring it to subjection; but to conquer and curb it a thousand times better, put thou upon it the bridle of love. With love thou overcomest it most surely, with love thou loadest it most heavily. God lies in wait for us therefore with nothing so much as with love. For love is like the fisherman's hook. To the fisherman falls no fish that is not caught on his hook. Once it takes the hook the fish is forfeit to the fisherman; in vain it twists hither and thither, the fisherman is certain of his catch. And so I say of love: he who is caught thereby has the strongest of all bonds and yet a pleasant burden. He who bears this sweet burden fares further, gets nearer therewith than by using any harshness possible to man. Moreover, he can cheerfully put up with whatever befalls, cheerfully suffer what God inflicts. Naught makes thee so much God nor God so much thine own as this sweet bond. He who has found this way will seek no other. He who hangs on this hook is so fast caught that foot and hand, mouth, eyes and heart and all that is man's is bound to be God's.

So then thou canst not, better than by love, prevail over thy foe and stop him doing thee a mischief. Wherefore it is written: 'Love is strong as death and hard as hell.' Death separates soul from body, but love separates all things from the soul; she will not tolerate at any cost what is not God nor God's. Who is caught in this net, who walks in this way, whatsoever he works is wrought by love, whose alone the work is: busy or idle it matters nothing. Such an one's most trivial action is more profitable, his meanest occupation is more fruitful to himself and other people and to God is better pleasing than the cumulative works of other men, who, though free from mortal sin, are yet inferior to him in love. He rests more usefully than others labour.

Await thou therefore this book, so thou be happily caught, and the more surely caught so much the more surely freed.

That we may be thus caught and freed, help us thou who art love itself. Amen.

Go deeper with this sermon

The spiritual guide to Sermon 4

The guide walks you through the inner journey this sermon describes, where it meets your own days, and the ways people go wrong trying to live it. It ends with a practice for the week, a meditation and questions for reflection.

It is in Sermons of Meister Eckhart, Explained, Volume 1.

Get Volume 1

Live this teaching

Detachment is Week 2 of The Ground of the Soul

An 8-week guided path with daily practices, weekly guided audio and a workbook.

See the course