Sermon 50
How the Father's going out becomes the soul's going in
Sermon 50 (Evans numbering). On John 16:28 - "I came forth from the Father and am come into the world: again, I leave the world, and go to the Father."
In brief
This sermon starts from a single verse in John's Gospel, where Jesus says he came from the Father and is going back to the Father. Eckhart uses it to talk about how God's life moves: out from the Father into the Son, out from the Son into the world and into the soul, and then back again. He describes one single motion, seen from different sides, rather than three separate journeys.
Along the way he gives one of his most quoted images, a stone dropped into a pond, with rings spreading out from Father to Son to angel to creature, each ring weaker in force but wider in reach. Then he turns the whole thing inside out: the Son's going out from the Father is, at the very same time, his coming into the soul, and the soul's own return to God is not a separate trip either. Going out and coming home turn out to be the same motion, looked at from two sides.
In plain English
Sermon 50
Exivi a patre et veni in mundum (John 16:28), I came forth from the Father and have come into the world. I take this from the Gospel of John. Our Lord says, 'I came forth from the Father and have come into the world, and now I am leaving the world again and returning to the Father.' He says elsewhere, 'Truly, truly I tell you, whatever you ask the Father in my name, you will receive.' Scholars say the word amen is a word for steadiness. Our Lord says, 'Heaven and earth will pass away before my word passes away,' and his word never changes. The heavens are many, and the countless stars are each a single color. The moon alone is mottled, thick and clear, dark and light, and that comes from its closeness to the earth. Our teachers tell us that in God there is no yesterday and no tomorrow, it is always today and now in God. Augustine notes that an architect who builds a house shows his skill in the house, and even if the house falls into ruin, the skill in his soul neither ages nor decays. And Augustine also says that all things are unchanging in the eternal Word, and do not wear away, even though in themselves they are subject to decay, able either to exist in some way or not to exist at all.
He says 'truly' (meaning without fail, always), 'whatever you ask of my Father in my name you will receive.' According to Augustine, to pray to God for anything other than God is not to pray at all. John of Damascus says that when the soul sees herself she sees spirit, and when she sees an angel she sees spirit, yet beside God both she and the angel are merely bodily things. Their minds are like matter compared to God. Angelic light is darkness next to him. Our Lord says, 'Truly I tell you, whatever you ask in my name you will receive,' meaning that what is in man's name is man, what is in light's name is light, and what is in God's name is fixed and unchanging. The name of God belongs to no one but the one who stands in this light. No one can say 'Father' unless he is a son, and no one is called son unless he is one with the only-begotten Word. Whoever asks in God's name can ask the Father for whatever he wants. Words have great power, and they get it from the flowing forth of the eternal Word.
Our Lord says, 'I have come into the world.' The Father comes into his Son with everything he is, he comes into his Son with everything he has, he comes into his Son with everything he gives, and fourth, he comes in an act of understanding. It belongs to the Son to dwell in the Father, and it belongs to the Father to dwell in his Son and in the Holy Spirit. The full promise of the Father is brought out in the Son so that the Son may pass it on to the soul. Here is a comparison I like to use. When you throw a stone into a pond, the impact starts a circle, small but forceful, which sets off other circles, the second one bigger than the first though less forceful, and the third bigger still. One comes out of another without stopping, and if the throw was hard enough, the ripples would reach the edge of the water before they died out. If the throw were strong enough and the whole world were a sheet of water, the water would run out before the circles stopped spreading.
Now notice how this applies. First, out of the Father there leaps the Son, small, yet so filled with divine strength that he is the cause of the whole outpouring. The second outpouring is the highest angel, following right after the first event. It moves quickly, and though it has less force than the first, and is itself small, it carries enough power that its surplus strength feeds the lower angels, while the circles that follow, spreading wider still, are larger in range than the second or the first. They keep pouring out, one after another, all busy spreading themselves from the highest angel down to the lowest, but however far it is from the first outpouring of the eternal Word to the first angel, that angel remains too high to be touched by anything bodily. Further, our master claims that even the lowest angel, because of his power flowing from God, holds so much of God's strength that the smallest trace of his activity, like a chip struck off by a carpenter's axe, makes everything grow and flourish. If that chip ever stopped falling from his work, everything would perish at once. They spread far and wide, reflecting as far as they can the first outpouring of the Son from the Father. But that first outpouring carried so much power that if there were a thousand worlds or more, they would run out of room before that first flow had been spent, just as the water's edge was reached before the ripples died out that came from the stone striking the pond.
Our Lord says, 'I came forth from the Father and have come into the world.' Here 'world' means pure, or virgin. He is speaking of the soul. Boethius says the world of the soul is called pure because she is formed like the fair, virgin world that exists in God. And God is that soul who has shaped herself into the perfect image of the divine world and stays there completely, not looking outward but, set apart from the outer world, standing still in the world of light within God. Into this soul the Son comes, begotten there with the full splendor of God: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, all together in one perfect being. The soul that has the Son within her holds, in one perfect being, the entire promise of the Godhead. One more thing: creatures give of themselves only so far as they are good. It belongs to God alone, as the wholly good one, that whoever shares in him receives him completely, in his Son. This is another reason the soul who has the Son receives the whole Godhead. Third, the Father carries out, in his Son, an act of understanding. According to the philosophers, the highest happiness for a human being lies in the exercise of the mind in wisdom. And the Father's whole delight, his perfect joy, is this act of understanding, which is the birth of his Son. He takes such joy in this birth that he puts his whole power and his whole nature into it. So the soul who has received the Son through an act of understanding possesses, in him, everything God can give, in one perfect joy and bliss.
Our Lord says, 'I came forth from the Father and have come into this world,' meaning the world of light. The soul, the true reflection of the divine world, is the one the Son enters. Just as he comes forth from the Father, he is born in the soul. In this same birth he is born into the world, into the soul, and lifting her up he brings her to birth in the Father. As he says, 'Again I leave the world,' the outer world, 'and go back up to my Father,' taking with him the light-world of the soul, the copy of the divine world, made on the same pattern, in the same likeness. He carries her up to his Father, into the first ground, the ground from which the Son comes out and descends from the Father.
There is another meaning in his words 'I came forth from the Father,' which is this: the Father enters his Son with the whole of his divinity, for he is entirely understanding. He goes completely into his Son. If he had more sons, they would receive nothing, for he can never have more than one Son, since he is nothing other than his own understanding. If he had a thousand sons, they would all have to be the same Son.
Our Lord says, 'I came forth from the Father and have come into the world. Again I am leaving the world and returning to the Father.' He means that his going out is his going into the soul. But her going in is her going out. The soul moves from her outermost part into her innermost, from what is her own into what belongs to the Son. Her being lifted up to the Father is the same as his leaving the outer world and, with the soul, going up again to his Father. Mark tells of someone calling our Lord 'Good Master.' He answered, 'No one is good but God,' because in coming forth he falls entirely into the soul with everything he is. No creature can give itself completely, it gives itself in kindness and in work but keeps itself at home. His going out is his coming in. His passing out of the Father is his passing into the soul. His outpouring is truly God giving himself once and for all in his Son. We say that the only-begotten Son who comes forth from the Father is the same as the Father himself. From the moment the Father pours himself out fully in the Son, the Father returns to pure being. He has no other course, since he has spent his whole substance on his Son. If there were no time, no place, no matter, nothing left at all, the one who begets would be the same as the one begotten. So the Son, as we call him, must be the only Son, one with the Father, who speaks in a single Word the whole of what he knows and the whole of what he can give, in a single instant, and that instant is eternal.
Now our teachers say that natural acts move toward unity. God gives himself, hands himself over, whole, to the soul, so that she may be one with him. And his first outpouring is his only Son. Our teachers also tell us that the highest angel is pure, yet still belongs to nature. But the only Son never entered any nature, he remained above nature, in pure being he went into the Father. The second outpouring into nature, as our masters say, the highest spirit, stayed by nature simple, matching the closeness of his nature to its source. He broke in so that he could let us out: his going out from there is his coming in here. That is the meaning of his words, 'Let...'
Plain-English version by Gregory Lahn, from C. de B. Evans's translation of Franz Pfeiffer's edition (London, 1924), which is in the public domain.
Read the 1924 translation
I CAME FORTH FROM THE FATHER
Exivi a patre et veni in mundum (Joh. xvi. 28). I quote from the Gospel of St John. Our Lord says, 'I came forth from the Father and am come into the world and again I leave the world and return to my Father.' Another of his sayings is, 'Amen, Verily I say unto you whatsoever ye shall ask of the Father in my name the same shall be yours.' Scholars say the word amen is an expression for stability. Our Lord says, 'Heaven and earth shall pass away before my word shall pass away,' which never changes. The heavens which are manifold and the unnumbered stars are all self-coloured. The moon alone is pied, thick and clear, dark and light. That is due to the neighbourhood of earth. And our doctors teach that in God there is no yesterday nor morrow, it is to-day and now all the time in God. Augustine observes that the architect who builds a house therein displays his art; though it may fall to ruin the art within his soul neither ages nor decays. And again Augustine says, 'All things are immutable in the eternal Word, nor do they wear away albeit in themselves they are corruptible, apt to be in some sort or not to be at all.'
He says, 'Verily' (i.e. without fail or invariably), 'whatsoever ye ask of my Father in my name the same shall be yours.' According to St Augustine, 'To pray to God for aught save God is not to pray at all.' John Damascene declares that 'seeing herself the soul sees spirit; seeing an angel she sees spirit, yet, beholding God, she and the angel are but corporal things compared with him.' Their mind is as matter to God. Angelic light is darkness as compared with him. Our Lord says, 'Verily, I say unto you, whatsoever ye ask in my name the same shall be yours,' meaning, what is in man's name is man; what is in light's name is light; what is in God's name is fixed and immutable. The name of God belongs to none but him who stands in this light. No man can say Father except he be Son and none is called Son unless he be one with the one-begotten Word. Whoso asks in God's name may demand of the Father whatever he will. Words have enormous power and have gotten it from the emanation of the eternal Word.
Our Lord says, 'I am come into the world.' The Father comes into his Son with all he is, he comes into his Son with all he has, he comes into his Son with all that he affords and, fourthly, he comes in an intellectual act. It is proper to the Son to dwell in the Father and it is proper to the Father to dwell in his Son and in the Holy Ghost. The full promise of the Father is brought forth in the Son to the end that the Son may transmit it to the soul. To use a favourite simile of mine. When a stone is thrown into a pond the impact starts a circle, small but energetic, which sets up other circles, the second being larger than the first albeit not so potent and the third one bigger still; one is gotten from another without stopping; and if the throw was hard enough the water's edge is reached before the ripples are exhausted. One unique throw with the world a sheet of water and the water would fail ere the circles died away.
Now mark the application. First, out of the Father there leaps forth the Son, small, but so puissant in his godly strength that it is he who causes the whole emanation. The second sally is the premier angel, following hard upon the first event. It speeds apace, and though less energetic than the first and fully small, it is endowed with so much force that its superfluous energy supplies the lower angels while its successors, yet more widely flung, are bigger in circumference than the second or the first. They keep on brimming out the one behind the other, all busy pouring themselves forth from the highest to the lowest of the angels; but however far it be from the initial sally of the eternal Word to the first angel, this latter is too high to be affected by any corporal thing. Further. Our master claims for the lowest of the angels that in view of his energy projecting into God, the very basest of the inferior angels has so much of God's might that the smallest fraction (a chip as it were from the carpenter's axe), the minutest trace, of his activity makes all things grow and flourish. If this chip does not fall from his work, everything instantly perishes. They spread far and wide, reproducing so far as they may the first welling out of the Son from the Father; but this first emanation was so charged with power that given a thousand or more worlds they would be wanting in capacity ere the first issue had been spent, just as the water's edge was reached before the ripples were exhausted that arose from the impact of the stone.
Our Lord says, 'I came forth from the Father and am come into the world.' World meaning pure or virgin. He is referring to the soul. Boethius says the world of the soul is called pure because she is fashioned like the fair and virgin world in God. And God is that soul which has gotten her into the perfect image of the divine world and wholly there abides, not peering forth but, all aloof from the outside world, standing still in the light-world in God. Into this soul comes the Son, begotten there in all the panoply of God: Father, Son and Holy Ghost, all together in one perfect being. The soul that has gotten in her the Son, has in one perfect entity the entire promise of the Godhead. One thing more. Creatures communicate themselves so far as they are good. It is peculiar to God as being wholly good that into whomsoever does partake of him he empties himself wholly in his Son. Which is another argument for the soul who has gotten the Son receiving the Godhead altogether. Thirdly, the Father is performing, in his Son, an intellectual operation. According to the philosophers, man's highest happiness consists in the mental exercise of wisdom. And the Father's whole delight, his perfect bliss, is this intellectual wont which is the birth of his Son. This birth he so enjoys that he puts his whole might into it and his entire nature. Accordingly the soul having gotten the Son by a feat of understanding, in him possesses all that God can give, in one perfect joy and bliss.
Our Lord says, 'I came forth from the Father and am come into this world,' into the light-world, that is. The soul, true reflection of the divine world, into her enters the Son; just as he falls from the Father he is born in the soul. In this very same birth he is born in the world, in the soul, and bearing her up brings her to birth in the Father. As he says, 'again I leave the world,' the outer world, and 're-ascend to my Father,' with the light-world of the soul, copy of the world divine, made on the same last, in the same likeness. He carries her up to his Father, into the first, into the ground whence the Son comes out and strikes down from the Father.
There is another meaning in his words, 'I came forth from the Father,' which is this: the Father goes into his Son in all his deity, for he is wholly intellectual. He goes clean into his Son. Had he more sons they would get naught; he could never have but one Son for he is none other than his understanding. Had he a thousand sons they must needs be all the same Son.
Our Lord says, 'I came forth from the Father and am come into the world. Again I leave the world and return to my Father.' He implies that his going out is his going into the soul. But her going in is her going out. The soul goes out of her outermost into her innermost, out of her own into the Son's. Her being caught up to the Father is his quitting the outer world and, with the soul, ascending once more to his Father. Mark tells of someone addressing our Lord as 'Good Master.' He replied, 'There is none good but God,' for in coming forth he falls clean into the soul with all he is. No creature exists that can give itself whole; it goes out in kindness and work but itself stays at home. His exit is his entrance. His passage out of the Father is his passage into the soul. His emanation verily is God giving himself once for all in his Son. We say: the only-begotten Son who proceeds from the Father is the same as himself. From the moment the Father launches forth in all his might in the Son, he (the Father) reverts to pure essence. He has no other course seeing he has spent all his substance on his Son. Were there no time nor place nor matter, nothing left at all, the begetter would be as the begotten. It follows that the Son so called, must be the only Son and be one with the Father who utters in one single Word the whole of what he knows, the whole of what he can afford, in one single instant, and that instant is eternal.
Now our doctors say: natural acts make for unity. God vouchsafes himself, gives himself, as a whole to the soul in order that she may be one with him. Moreover, his first issue is his only Son. Again, our doctors teach that the highest of the angels is pure yet he forms a part of nature. But the only Son never entered any nature, he remained superior to nature: in pure being he went into the Father. The second eruption into nature, so our masters say, the highest spirit, remained by nature simplex, one in proportion to the nearness of his nature (to its origin). He broke in to let us out: his exit thence is his entrance here. Hence his words, 'Let. . . .'
Go deeper with this sermon
The spiritual guide to Sermon 50
The guide walks you through the inner journey this sermon describes, where it meets your own days, and the ways people go wrong trying to live it. It ends with a practice for the week, a meditation and questions for reflection.
It is in Sermons of Meister Eckhart, Explained, Volume 4.
Live this teaching
The birth of God in the soul is Week 5 of The Ground of the Soul
An 8-week guided path with daily practices, weekly guided audio and a workbook.
Free by email
30 Days with Meister Eckhart
One short passage from his sermons each day for thirty days, with a plain paragraph on what he means. It is free, and leaving takes one click.