Meister Eckhart

Library › Sermon 72

Sermon 72

On mercy, detachment, and the Pharisee who asked Christ to dine

Sermon 72 (Evans numbering). On Lord, be merciful to the people that is in thee.

In brief

This sermon starts from a small gospel scene: a Pharisee invites Jesus to dine with him, and elsewhere Jesus tells a woman to 'go in peace.' Eckhart uses these two moments to ask what real peace is. He says it is not enough to move from trouble to calm. A person is meant to enter peace, stay in it, and end in it, because that is simply what it means to be in God.

From there Eckhart does something surprising with the word 'Pharisee.' Instead of treating it as an insult, he reads it as meaning someone set apart, someone detached. He uses that picture to talk about mercy, which he describes as God's constant work of drawing a soul toward the highest thing it can receive, a work that happens in a place deeper than thinking or wanting, in what he calls the ground of the soul.

In plain English

Sermon 72

The prophet said, 'Lord, be merciful to the people who are in you.' The Lord replied, 'All who enter in, I will make whole and love greatly.'

I take up the words of the Pharisee who asked our Lord to dine with him, and our Lord's words to the woman, vade in pace, go in peace. It is good to pass from restlessness to calm: this is praiseworthy but imperfect. 'Go in peace': be not troubled. God means that we should enter into peace, continue in peace, and end in peace. God said, 'In me you have peace.' As far as one is in God, so far one is in peace. Whatever is in God is in peace; whatever is outside God is without peace. St. John says, 'Whatever is born of God overcomes the world.' What is born of God seeks peace and follows after it. He who keeps to the even course of his way and is at peace is a heavenly man. Heaven is always turning, and in its turning it seeks rest.

See also Jostes, No. 10.

The Pharisee asked our Lord to dine with him. The food a person eats is changed within them into their own body, just as the body is changed by the soul. Body and soul are one in being, though not in activity: my soul is united with my eye in one particular way, that of seeing. In the same way the food a person eats mingles with their nature in its essence but not in its activity. And the great union we are destined for with God will be a union of essence, not of operation. This is why the Pharisee asked that God would eat with him.

Pharisee means a solitary person, one who knows no limit to the detachment of the soul. The nobler the powers, the more freedom they bring. Some powers stand far above the body and are detached enough to separate and release themselves completely. As the philosopher rightly says, 'What moves mortal things does not itself enter into them.' Again, by being free and unattached, the unlearned person may, in love and longing, receive wisdom and pass it on. And third, having no end means having no final stopping point, no lasting security, until one comes to rest and is untroubled by disturbance: until the powers of the soul, fixed on God, are wholly free of attachment. As the prophet cries, 'Lord, be merciful to the people who are in you.'

One master says, 'Of all the exalted works God has ever done in creatures, mercy is the most familiar and the most mysterious, not excepting his work in the angels.' Here the work of mercy is raised up to mercy as it is in itself and as it is in God. The first outcome of God's activity is mercy, not in the sense of forgiving a person's sins, nor in the sense of one person forgiving another. His highest work is mercy in the sense that he brings the soul into the highest and most perfect thing she can conceive in this world. In his bottomless ocean, God is forever producing mercy.

The prophet said, 'Lord, be merciful to the people who are in you.' What people is in God? St. John says, 'He who dwells in love dwells in God, and God in him.' St. John says, 'Love unites, love brings one into God.' Perhaps that is only secondary. Love does not unite, not in any way. Being satisfied, or having enough, is not what holds things together or binds them together. Love unites in act, not in essence. The best authorities hold that the intellect strips everything away and grasps God bare, as pure being in himself. Intellect penetrates goodness and truth, and, coming upon the unmixed essence, it seizes God in the abstract, as being without name. Neither knowledge nor love unites anything. Love takes God only under the aspect of goodness, and God escapes beyond that name. Good is as far as love goes. Love takes God under a veil, under a garment. Not so with understanding: understanding takes God as he is known in himself, though it can never grasp him in the depths of his own unfathomable nature. Above both these ways of knowing, God is at work as mercy, at the height and perfection of his activity.

A philosopher says, 'There is something in the soul, intimate and hidden, far higher than the soul herself, from which her powers of intellect and will flow.' St. Augustine says, 'Just as that is ineffable out of which the Son leaps forth from the Father in the first procession,' so there is some hidden thing behind the first procession of intellect and will. According to the philosopher who is our chief authority on the soul, no human wisdom can ever grasp what the soul is. That requires a wisdom beyond nature. We do not know the source from which the powers of the soul come forth into act: of that perhaps we know a little, but what the soul is in her ground, no one knows. Whatever knowledge of this we may be allowed must come from beyond nature, by grace: God's agent of mercy.

Plain-English version by Gregory Lahn, from C. de B. Evans's translation of Franz Pfeiffer's edition (London, 1924), which is in the public domain.

Read the 1924 translation

THE PROPHET SAYS: LORD BE MERCIFUL

The prophet said, 'Lord be merciful to the people that is in thee.' The Lord replied, 'All that enter in will I make whole and love much.'

I take the words of the Pharisee who besought our Lord to dine with him and our Lord's injunction to the woman, vade in pace! It is good to pass from restlessness to calm: praiseworthy but imperfect. 'Go in peace,' be not disquieted: God implies that we ought to enter into peace and continue in peace and end in peace. God said, 'In me ye have peace.' So far in God so far in peace. Is aught in God, it is in peace; is aught out of God, it is without peace. St John says, 'Whatever is born of God overcometh the world.' What is born of God seeks peace and ensues it. He that pursues the even tenor of his way and is at peace is a heavenly man. Heaven constantly rotates, in its motion seeking rest.

1 See also Jostes, No. 10.

The Pharisee besought our Lord that he would dine with him. The food a man eats is changed in him into his body, like the body by the soul. Body and soul are one in being, not in act, thus my soul is united with my eye in one mode, that of seeing. Even so the food a man consumes mingles with his nature as regards its essence but not its activity; and the great atonement we are destined to with God shall be of essence not of operation. Hence the Pharisee's request that God would eat with him.

Pharisee signifies a solitary, one who knows no end to detachment of soul. The more noble the powers the more they liberate. Some powers are far higher than the body and sufficiently aloof to shell off and detach completely. As the philosopher well says, 'What once moves mortal things never enters into them.' Again, by being free and unattached the unlettered man may in love and longing receive wisdom and impart it. And thirdly, having no end means having no finality, no ultimate security until one is at rest and all unwitting of disquiet: until the soul-powers being fixed on God are wholly unattached. As the prophet cries, 'Lord be merciful to the people that are in thee.'

One master says, 'Of all the exalted works God has ever wrought in creatures mercy is the most familiar and the most mysterious, his work in the angels not excepted.' In it the work of mercy is exalted to mercy as it is in itself and as it is in God. Of God's activity the first outcome is mercy; not in the sense of his forgiving man's sins nor of one man's forgiving another; his highest work is mercy in the sense that he initiates the soul into the highest and most perfect thing she can conceive in this world. In his bottomless ocean God is productive of mercy.

The prophet said, 'Lord be merciful to the people that is in thee.' What people is in God? St John says, 'He that dwelleth in love dwelleth in God and God in him.' St John says, 'Love unites, love initiates into God.' Haply it is accessory. Love does not unite, not in any wise. Satisfaction (or, enough) is not what holds together, binds together. Love unites in act and not in essence. The best authorities aver that intellect strips everything off and grasps God bare as pure being in itself. Intellect penetrates goodness and truth, and, lighting on virgin essence, it seizes God in the abstract as pure being, without name. Neither knowledge nor love unites aught. Love takes God only as being good and God escapes from name. Good, love goes no further than that. Love takes God under a veil, under a garment. Not so understanding: understanding takes God as he is known in itself; it can never comprehend him in the sea of his own unfathomable nature. Above both these perceptions God energises as mercy at the summit and perfection of his activity.

A philosopher says, 'There is something in the soul, intimate, mysterious, far higher than the soul herself, whence emanate her powers of intellect and will.' St Augustine says: 'Just as that is ineffable out of which the Son leaps from the Father in the first procession,' there exists some occult thing behind the first procession of intellect and will. According to the philosopher who is our chief authority upon the soul, no human wisdom ever can attain to what the soul is. That requires supernatural wisdom. What the powers of the soul issue from into act, we do not know: about it haply we do know a little, but what the soul is in her ground no man knows. Any knowledge thereof that may be permitted to us must be supernatural; it must be by grace: God's agent of mercy.

Go deeper with this sermon

The spiritual guide to Sermon 72

The guide walks you through the inner journey this sermon describes, where it meets your own days, and the ways people go wrong trying to live it. It ends with a practice for the week, a meditation and questions for reflection.

It is in Sermons of Meister Eckhart, Explained, Volume 5.

Get Volume 5

Live this teaching

Detachment is Week 2 of The Ground of the Soul

An 8-week guided path with daily practices, weekly guided audio and a workbook.

See the course