Meister Eckhart

Library › Sermon 98

Sermon 98

Going up the mountain: knowing God without image

Sermon 98 (Evans numbering). On Videns Jesus turbas ascendit in montem etc, (Matt. 5)

In brief

Eckhart starts from the line in Matthew where Jesus leaves the crowd and goes up a mountain to teach. For Eckhart this is never just a story about geography. The crowd stands for the many scattered things that pull a person outward, and the mountain stands for the quiet, gathered place inside where God actually speaks. Before God can teach anything, a person has to stop chasing after so many things and so many thoughts, even good ones, and come back to themselves.

From there he moves into how God is known at that depth. Ordinary knowing works through pictures and likenesses, the way the eye takes in color or the mind holds an image of something bodily. But the highest knowing, the kind Eckhart says belongs to angels and to the deepest point of the soul, has no picture in it at all. He pushes this all the way to a strange, bracing image: real light, in this sense, looks like darkness to us, because it has nothing in it that our senses or our ordinary thinking can grab hold of.

In plain English

Sermon 98

Videns Jesus turbas ascendit in montem etc. (Matt. 5), When Jesus saw the crowds he went up into a mountain. We read in the gospel that our Lord departed from the crowd and went up into the mountain. There he opened his mouth and taught them about the kingdom of God.

St Augustine says, The student of this subject sets his stool in heaven. The student of God must rise above things that are scattered: these he must avoid. To take in God's instruction he must gather himself together and withdraw into himself, turning his back on care and the pursuit of lower things and on his powers, so many and so various. He must leave all these behind, even as they exist in his thought, though thought does work wonders in itself. These thoughts must be gone beyond if God is to speak into the powers which are not separate.

Again: "He went up into the mountain" implies that God is sharing the sublimity and sweetness of his nature. In this intuition, where everything that is creature must fall away, he is aware of nothing but God and himself as the image of God.

Thirdly: his going up into the mountain means his exaltation (what is high is near to God) and concerns the powers that border on divinity. On one occasion our Lord took three of his disciples and led them up into a mountain where he appeared before them in that same light-body in which we shall see him in eternal life. Our Lord said to the children of Israel, "Remember what I told you about heaven: you see there neither image nor form nor any likeness." When a man leaves the crowd, God comes into his soul without image or likeness.

St Augustine teaches about three kinds of knowledge. The first is bodily: the eye, for instance, is sensible of images. The second is mental but still admits images of bodily things. The third is in the interior mind, which knows without image or likeness, and this knowledge is like that of the angels.

The higher angels are divided into three. One philosopher says, The soul knows only in effigy. Things are all known in image and likeness, but angels know themselves without likeness, and God. What he means to say is this: God shares himself with the soul at her summit without image or likeness.

He went up into the mountain and was transfigured before them. The soul must be transfigured or re-formed and sealed and re-cast in his form. I maintain that the soul transcends form, she being cast in the form of God's Son. According to the masters, the Son is the image of God and the soul is formed in his image. I agree. But the Son is the image of God above form: the form of his hidden Godhead: the Son as the idea, as the conception of God, that is the form of the soul. By the fact that the Son loves, the soul loves also. Where the Son is proceeding is not where the soul hangs: she is above form. Fire and heat are one and yet far from the same. Taste and hue in an apple are one but by no means identical. The tongue can

taste things which are lost on the eye; the eye perceives colors the tongue knows nothing of. The soul knows one thing only; she is above form.

The prophet says: God will lead his sheep into green pastures. "Sheep" is in the singular; and so are they singular who are made simple into one. A philosopher says that nowhere is the heavenly course so clear as in the simple hearts who innocently accept the heavenly influence, and in children with no mind of their own. Clever and active-minded people are carried away into many scattered things. Our Lord promises to feed his sheep in the original mountain pastures, on green grass. In God all creatures exist in embryo. First, all creatures come forth from God, and then the angels. To have the nature of one particular creature is to bear the stamp of creatures as a whole. An angel's nature bears the impress of all creatures. All that angelic nature can receive is summed up in him. Whatever God chooses to create, his angels take in on pain of missing the perfection that belongs to other creatures.

St Augustine says: What God creates has a channel through the angels on high, where on the hilltops everything is flourishing, where creatures are all fresh and green. Falling into time they droop and fade. Among the young green of all creatures there, our Lord pastures his sheep. Creatures which flourish on these green heights are, as they exist in the angels, more pleasing to the soul than all the things of this world. The lowest of creatures, as it is there, is to this world as day is to night.

Whoever would be taught by God has to go up this mountain; there God will perfect them in the day of eternity when the light is full. What I perceive in God is light; what touches creatures is darkness. The true light has no contact with creatures. Spiritual perception is light. St John says, "God is the true light that shines in the darkness." What is the darkness? In the first place, independence, detachment: being blind and unaware of creatures. As I have often said, to see God we have to be blind. Again, God is the light which shines in the darkness. He is the blinding light. That is, light beyond understanding, without limit, that knows no end. Its blinding the soul means that she knows nothing, is aware of nothing. The third darkness is best of all: there is no light. A master says, Heaven has no light, it is too high up for that; it does not shine and in itself is neither hot nor cold. In this darkness the soul has lost all light, she has outgrown what we call light and color.

A philosopher says: Light is the Supreme, God's promised land. A philosopher says: The fulfillment of every desire is brought to the soul in this light. A philosopher says: There never was anything fine enough to enter the ground of the soul

but God only. Meaning to say: God shines in that darkness where the soul goes beyond all light. For though her powers are open to sweetness and light and grace, yet into the ground of the soul she lets in nothing but God alone. Whatever else of sweetness and light proceeds from him, she receives only into her powers.

According to our best authorities the powers of the soul and she herself are one: fire and fire-light are one, and where it (light) changes into reason it changes into another nature. Where intellect issues from the soul it invents another nature. Thirdly, the light of lights, where soul goes beyond all light, is on the mountain summit where no light exists. Where God breaks out into his Son is not where the soul hangs from. Where God is proceeding, where we know God somewhat, is not where the soul is suspended, it is infinitely higher up than that; she goes entirely beyond light and knowledge. He says, I will deliver them and will gather them together and bring them into their own land where I will lead them into green pastures (upon the mountain of Israel). Upon this mountain he opened his mouth. One doctor says: Our Lord opens his mouth here below, leading us by the scriptures and by means of creatures. But St Paul says, Now God has spoken to us in his only-begotten Son, in whom I know, from the least to the greatest, all at once in God. May we outgrow whatever is not God. So help us God.

Plain-English version by Gregory Lahn, from C. de B. Evans's translation of Franz Pfeiffer's edition (London, 1924), which is in the public domain.

Read the 1924 translation

HE WENT UP INTO A MOUNTAIN

Videns Jesus turbas ascendit in montem etc. (Matt. 5). We read in the gospel that our Lord departed from the multitude and ascended into the mountain. There he opened his mouth and taught them about the kingdom of God.

St Augustine says, 'The student of this subject sets his stool in heaven.' The student of God must rise above things scattered: these he must eschew. To take in God's instruction he must gather himself together and withdraw into himself, turning his back on care and the pursuit of nether things and on his powers so many and so various. He must leave all these behind, even as existing in his thought, not but what thought works wonders in itself. These thoughts must be transcended if God is to speak into the powers which are inseparate.

Again: 'He went up into the mountain' implies that God is imparting the sublimity and sweetness of his nature. In this intuition wherein there must needs fall away everything that is creature, he is aware of nothing but God and himself as the image of God.

Thirdly: his ascent into the mountain betokens his exaltation (what is high is near to God) and concerns the powers trenching on divinity. Upon one occasion our Lord took three of his disciples and led them up into a mountain where he appeared before them in that same light-body wherein we shall see him in eternal life. Our Lord said to the children of Israel, 'Remember what I told you about heaven: ye see there neither image nor form nor any likeness.' When a man does leave the multitude God comes into his soul without image or likeness.

St Augustine teaches about three kinds of knowledge. The first is bodily: the eye, for instance, is sensible of images. The second is mental but still admits of images of bodily things. The third is in the interior mind, which knows without image or likeness, and this knowledge is like unto the angels.

The higher angels are divided into three. One philosopher says, 'The soul knows only in effigy. Things are all known in image and likeness, but angels know themselves without likeness, and God.' What he means to say is: God imparts himself to the soul at her summit without image or likeness.

He went up into the mountain and was transfigured before them. The soul must be transfigured or re-formed and sealed and re-cast in his form. I maintain that the soul transcends form, she being cast in the form of God's Son. According to the masters, the Son is the image of God and the soul is formed in his image. I agree. But the Son is the image of God above form: the form of his concealed Godhead: the Son as the idea, as the conception of God, that is the form of the soul. By the fact that the Son loves the soul loves also. Where the Son is proceeding is not where the soul is suspended: she is above form. Fire and heat are one and yet far from the same. Taste and hue in an apple are one but by no means identical. The tongue can taste things which are lost on the eye; the eye perceives colours the tongue knows not of. The soul knows one only; she is above form.

The prophet says: God will lead his sheep into green pastures. Sheep is in the singular; and so are they singular who are simplified to one. A philosopher says, that nowhere is the heavenly course so plain as in the simple hearts who guilelessly accept the heavenly influence and in children with no mind of their own. The clever and active-minded people are carried away into multitudinous things. Our Lord promises to feed his sheep in the primitive mountain pastures, on green grass. In God all creatures are in embryo. First, all creatures sally forth from God and then the angels. To have the nature of one particular creature is to bear the stamp of creatures as a whole. An angel's nature bears the impress of all creatures. All that angelic nature can receive is summed up in him. Whatever God chooses to create his angels entertain on penalty of missing the perfection which belongs to other creatures.

St Augustine says: What God creates has a channel through the angels on high, where on the hill-tops everything is flourishing, where creatures are all fresh and green. Falling into time they droop and fade. Among the young green of all creatures there our Lord pastures his sheep. Creatures which flourish on these verdant heights are, as existing in the angels, more grateful to the soul than all the things of this world. The vilest of creatures as it is there, is to this world as day to night.

Whoever would be taught by God has to ascend this mountain; there God will perfect them in the day of eternity when the light is full. What I perceive in God is light; what touches creatures is darkness. The true light has no contact with creatures. Spiritual perception is light. St John says, 'God is the true light that shineth in the darkness.' What is the darkness? In the first place; independence, detachment: being blind and unaware of creatures. As I have frequently said; to see God we have to be blind. Again, God is the light which shines in the darkness. He is the blinding light. That is, light incomprehensible, illimitable, that knows no end. Its blinding the soul means that she knows nothing, is aware of nothing. The third darkness is best of all: there is no light. A master says, 'Heaven has no light, it is too high up for that; it does not shine and in itself is neither hot nor cold.' In this darkness the soul has lost all light, she has outgrown what we call light and colour.

A philosopher says: 'Light is the Supreme, God's promised land.' A philosopher says, 'The realization of every desire is brought to the soul in this light.' A philosopher says: 'There never was anything subtile enough to enter the ground of the soul but God only.' Meaning to say: God shines in that darkness where the soul transcends all light. For what though her powers are open to sweetness and light and grace yet into the ground of the soul she lets nothing but absolute God. Whatever besides of sweetness and light proceeds from him she receives merely into her powers.

According to our best authorities the powers of the soul and she herself are one: fire and fire-light are one, and where it (light) changes to reason it changes to another nature. Where intellect issues from the soul it invents another nature. Thirdly, the light of lights where soul transcends all light is on the mountain summit where no light exists. Where God breaks out into his Son is not where the soul hangs from. Where God is proceeding, we knowing God somewhat, is not where the soul is suspended, it is infinitely higher up than that; she transcends light and knowledge completely. He says, 'I will deliver them and will gather them together and bring them into their own land where I will lead them into green pastures (upon the mountain of Israel).' Upon this mountain he opened his mouth. One doctor says: 'Our Lord opens his mouth here below leading us by the scriptures and by means of creatures.' But St Paul says, 'Now hath God spoken to us in his only-begotten Son in whom I know from the least to the greatest all at once in God.' May we out-grow whatever is not God. So help us God.

Go deeper with this sermon

The spiritual guide to Sermon 98

The guide walks you through the inner journey this sermon describes, where it meets your own days, and the ways people go wrong trying to live it. It ends with a practice for the week, a meditation and questions for reflection.

It is in Sermons of Meister Eckhart, Explained, Volume 7.

Get Volume 7

Live this teaching

Detachment is Week 2 of The Ground of the Soul

An 8-week guided path with daily practices, weekly guided audio and a workbook.

See the course